Andrea Badiali wrote: Wed Mar 10, 2021
Jeffrey Aley wrote: Tue Mar 09, 2021
What was the measurement while the laser was engraving (with the 4.7k ohm resistor in place) ?
 
The same when it didn't engrave, 23.1V.
 
This (the 23.1V) tells us that your controller is not attempting to turn on the "Wind".  This could be due to software or it could be due to a damaged controller.  The important information is that this is not an issue with the solenoid or anything else connected to the controller.  (It does not mean that the solenoid is good or bad, just that you have a problem BEFORE the solenoid.)
Your goal should be to leave the 4.7K resistor in place, and the volt meter, and see if you can get use software to get it to read approximately 0 Volts.
If you cannot, then you will need to change the controller.
Best of luck!